|
Post by metemeister on Dec 23, 2016 9:31:11 GMT -5
All of the versions of Millionaire are great in their own way; but seeing this version of the game die out so much faster than the others really made me sad. It's my opinion, but just seeing the clock forcing people to make decisions on huge amounts of money added a sense of tension and stress which no other version of the show could do for me. I can support that idea very easily. Think of it this way. When you watch someone run on Classic Millionaire, after some point you ask - when are they finally going to answer?!?! They just sit there contemplating what may happen after whatever they do. In the clocked, syndicated version, however, it was clear that contestants had to make quick and snappy choices on what to do, while also thinking about the risks. Just to compare, let's take this example of Rick's run in Clocked Millionaire: He constantly murmurs his thoughts in a very quick way, possibly to make a choice BEFORE the clock runs out. We never see a combination of brisk AND nervous thinking in an untimed version of Millionaire.
It is debatable that the other versions of Millionaire were more tense overall, but it is pretty certain that no other versions have the oddly satisfying combination between a quick and tense play style of the clocked one.
That's why I miss it.
What do you guys think? (Don't burn me on the stake, this is just my opinion! You can love Classic Millionaire for all I mind )
EDIT: Couldn't embed the video for it to end after the 25,000 dollar question. Sorry!
|
|
|
Post by Gagamillionaire on Dec 23, 2016 11:18:47 GMT -5
I'm kind of on the fence when it comes to the clock format. It looked and sounded great, that's for sure. But it was too rushed. I think it forced some people to walk away on a question they could have easily answered, had they had the time to properly think it through. 45 seconds for a question worth 5 or 6-figure sums is too little. The Japanese version had a clock for some time. If I remember correctly, they gave the players two minutes for the upper-tier questions, which is just right. You can ponder the question for a while, but then it's decision time. I also didn't hate the idea to only have a time limit for the first couple of questions, like on the UK version. I hate it when contestants drone on on a $2,000 question. If they need a little longer later, that's fine by me, as long as they don't take the whole show to decide.
Introducing the clock to the show made sense, but the show was already pretty hard, and adding another element of stress caused many to buckle. Still, it was the adjusted money tree (with the $5,000 milestone) and the removal of Ask the Expert that really broke the format.
|
|
|
Post by metemeister on Dec 24, 2016 2:59:17 GMT -5
Hmm... I kind of agree with the idea that the 5 to 6-figure valued questions should have more than 45 seconds. The Japanese version sounds plausible.
Although I do believe that the added difficulty made winning the million so much more unique and awesome, you are right that it was way too difficult for almost all of the contestants.
I still miss it though, and it's definitely a better choice than Shuffle Millionaire or the Millionaire right now. You'd agree, wouldn't you?
|
|
Peachfanclub
Fan Games Pass Holder
Enter your message here...
Posts: 985
|
Post by Peachfanclub on Feb 22, 2017 18:08:14 GMT -5
Boy, do I miss the Hot Seat. It would be the perfect environment for a guy like Regis to withstand for a good hour. He's the only guy I can see hosting a potential 20th anniversary special, but I couldn't stand to see him stand the whole hour. The rave format is clearly popular around the world, I can't see why the U.S. didn't adopt it.
Between all the formats the U.S. version has instated, I would've liked to see a revival of the classic, classic Millionaire; Super Millionaire is not a show you'd want to make into a regular series, and the clock and shuffle formats don't make Millionaire really feel like Millionaire. The current setup and how it looks is entirely appropriate for 2017, but I still think it's not quite ideal without the Hot Seat.
|
|