RegisFan
Administrator 
Game Show Host
Let's Play!
Posts: 4,494
|
Post by RegisFan on Jun 15, 2023 23:40:14 GMT -5
There’s no need to revisit The17thDoctor’s audition. The17thDoctor reached out via PM with her reasons for voting the way she did beyond what was shared above. My stance is that anything audition-related needs to be put in the audition thread itself so that the community can vote based on the evidence. FinalAnswer19 and I believe that voting should be member-driven unless something blatantly unfair happens. I’m this case, I will let The17thDoctor decide to either defend her vote above with further explanation within the 10-day audition window or we will have to toss out the “no” vote. |
|
|
|
Post by Minh Dang on Jun 16, 2023 0:43:26 GMT -5
There’s no need to revisit The17thDoctor’s audition. The17thDoctor reached out via PM with her reasons for voting the way she did beyond what was shared above. My stance is that anything audition-related needs to be put in the audition thread itself so that the community can vote based on the evidence. FinalAnswer19 and I believe that voting should be member-driven unless something blatantly unfair happens. I’m this case, I will let The17thDoctor decide to either defend her vote above with further explanation within the 10-day audition window or we will have to toss out the “no” vote. I'm kind of doubt on her reason. The fact that she only PM to you rather than defend it right in here in the first place is also weird. In any case, I'd also want to defend for a place in the Sharing Center before I think about re-audition in the future. In the end, I already have 8 "yes" votes already, and haven't violated any rules in this forum, I can't simply let my best attempt voided for an unclear reason. |
|
|
|
Post by The17thDoctor on Jun 16, 2023 3:41:17 GMT -5
There’s no need to revisit The17thDoctor ’s audition. The17thDoctor reached out via PM with her reasons for voting the way she did beyond what was shared above. My stance is that anything audition-related needs to be put in the audition thread itself so that the community can vote based on the evidence. FinalAnswer19 and I believe that voting should be member-driven unless something blatantly unfair happens. I’m this case, I will let The17thDoctor decide to either defend her vote above with further explanation within the 10-day audition window or we will have to toss out the “no” vote. With the clearly what I said, I will remain saying "no" to their audition. I PM you about my concern and I deeply thank you for solving this quickly I did put a tons of evidence of why I said "no" and I tried to make sure the auditions to be fair (even I have some bad decision, but this one I did not) I deeply apologize to people for not letting you all know earlier As for Minh Dang , I'm sorry but I will remain this as a no, I don't know if the past can against you from Fan Games, but for me, I do not like someone stealing materials and against people whenever if you're in the wrong side. |
|
|
|
Post by Minh Dang on Jun 16, 2023 4:18:34 GMT -5
There’s no need to revisit The17thDoctor ’s audition. The17thDoctor reached out via PM with her reasons for voting the way she did beyond what was shared above. My stance is that anything audition-related needs to be put in the audition thread itself so that the community can vote based on the evidence. FinalAnswer19 and I believe that voting should be member-driven unless something blatantly unfair happens. I’m this case, I will let The17thDoctor decide to either defend her vote above with further explanation within the 10-day audition window or we will have to toss out the “no” vote. With the clearly what I said, I will remain saying "no" to their audition. I PM you about my concern and I deeply thank you for solving this quickly I did put a tons of evidence of why I said "no" and I tried to make sure the auditions to be fair (even I have some bad decision, but this one I did not) I deeply apologize to people for not letting you all know earlier As for Minh Dang , I'm sorry but I will remain this as a no, I don't know if the past can against you from Fan Games, but for me, I do not like someone stealing materials and against people whenever if you're in the wrong side. One thing: The person who you mentioned... He have quit from making graphics for 2 years. And I also working on graphics myself for 1.5 years straight. For a very long time, I haven't asked someone else to help me unless I needed it. And I also credits them properly. There's no way you can say "no" to me for just that reason. I'm sorry, but I can't accept that reason from you. Become friend with a person who used to have a bad portfolio...DOESN'T MEAN that I'm also a person like him. And it's even more nonsense when he have quit already. |
|
Victor
Fan Games Pass Holder 
Posts: 151 
|
Post by Victor on Jun 16, 2023 5:28:10 GMT -5
This is an acceptable reason to say no.
What materials were stolen?
|
|
|
|
Post by Minh Dang on Jun 16, 2023 5:41:52 GMT -5
This is an acceptable reason to say no. What materials were stolen? Ok, let's said this clearly: I'm not stolen anything. She said no because I'm a friend of a person who used to be caught stealing. But he have quit making stuff like this by the time I begin to work in project like this. I also don't have his support in any of my projects. She's actually afraid that because I'm his friend, I might do that in the future(which is not what I'm gonna even think about) |
|
matt
Fan Games Pass Holder
An Italo-Spanish 20 y.o boy
Posts: 135
|
Post by matt on Jun 16, 2023 6:44:41 GMT -5
The17thDoctor - Not going to lie, I am more than sure that RegisFan has been very clear about what he asked you previously in this thread... so I'd really suggest you to read that question again, if you don't mind. He specifically said " In the boards" (meaning on this forum) and NOT on Discord. So I think there's no point pointing out things that didn't even happened here in the 1st place.
|
|
|
|
Post by FinalAnswer19 on Jun 16, 2023 16:27:50 GMT -5
The17thDoctor, it has been made clear that your evidence of the accusations that you sent us need to be posted here otherwise, your no vote will not be validated. You have a concern - and that's okay - but you are making broad accusations. The evidence needs to be posted here. If you cannot follow through with this request or rescind your no vote before the 10 day waiting period has elapsed, you will receive a warning level.
|
|
RegisFan
Administrator
Game Show Host
Let's Play!
Posts: 4,494
|
Post by RegisFan on Jun 17, 2023 2:00:24 GMT -5
The17thDoctor - Not going to lie, I am more than sure that RegisFan has been very clear about what he asked you previously in this thread... so I'd really suggest you to read that question again, if you don't mind. He specifically said " In the boards" (meaning on this forum) and NOT on Discord. So I think there's no point pointing out things that didn't even happened here in the 1st place. I wouldn’t turn away evidence from Discord if it was relevant to the argument at hand. But I do believe that any evidence should be shared publicly in this thread for everyone to digest and render judgment on. The whole reason this process works is because it’s transparent. If FinalAnswer19 and I privately decided the fate of each audition, it wouldn’t be a fair process. Just like in court, everyone is innocent until proven guilty and the verdict is decided by a group of the candidate’s peers. |
|
|
|
Post by Minh Dang on Jun 23, 2023 11:50:12 GMT -5
Thank you so much for voting and supported me in maybe, the biggest crisis since the day I joined in this place. For my last words, it's all in here! See you guys again!  |
|
|
|
Post by FinalAnswer19 on Jun 23, 2023 13:18:52 GMT -5
Because The17thDoctor failed to follow staff instructions, her warning level has been established, and “no” vote nullified. Closing this thread. |
|
) I guess the next on will be Poland then...
